Quoted from the New York Times:
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/06/dining/06burg.html?pagewanted=1&_r=1
The Favorites
These are the Burger of the Month Club’s top 10 burgers, in order:
PETER LUGER 178 Broadway (Driggs Avenue), Williamsburg, Brooklyn, (718) 387-7400.
DONOVAN’S PUB 57-24 Roosevelt Avenue, Woodside, Queens, (718) 429-9339.
CITY HALL 131 Duane Street (Church Street), TriBeCa (212) 227-7777.
PRIMEHOUSE 381 Park Avenue South (27th Street), (212) 824-2600.
BOBBY VAN’S GRILL 25 Broad Street (Exchange Place), Financial District, (212) 344-8463.
BURGER JOINT AT LE PARKER MERIDIEN 119 West 56th Street, Midtown, (212) 245-5000.
LANDMARC 179 West Broadway (Leonard Street), TriBeCa, (212) 343-3883.
GENESIS BAR & RESTAURANT 1708 Second Avenue (88th Street), Upper East Side, (212) 348-5500.
BLACK IRON BURGER 540 East Fifth Street (Avenue B), East Village, (212) 677-6067.
BACK FORTY 190 Avenue B (12th Street), East Village, (212) 388-1990.
(The Yelp reviews are terrible for black iron burger and back forty leave a comment if you disagree.)
These are some popular burgers with lower rankings:
CORNER BISTRO (21ST)
RARE BAR & GRILL (44TH)
SHAKE SHACK (30TH)
THE SPOTTED PIG (41ST)
VESELKA (28TH)